Update, Feb. 5, 2013: Hey, Hey! More Pictures are Coming In

Update, Jan. 28, See photos by clicking here.

1-23-13  update:  The work, obviously has fallen behind schedule and was not completed as the Sisters had hoped, by autumn.   The date for the dedication of the newly renovated chapel has been set for Feb. 3.

The following was sent in to our comment box, but it deserves a post of its own.  Thank you so much, Michael N. !

He wrote: “Here’s the story about Duncan Stroik’s project at the Carmelite Monastery in Traverse City.”

TRAVERSE CITY, MI – Duncan G. Stroik is one of the foremost church architects in the English-speaking world, the acknowledged leader of a growing movement to return classical ideas of beauty and harmony to sacred architecture.

His recent commissions have included the 2008 Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, WI, the 2009 Chapel of St. Thomas Aquinas College in Santa Paula, CA and the renovation of St. Joseph Cathedral in Sioux Falls, SD. A professor of architecture at the University of Notre Dame, he authored the book Reconquering Sacred Space and is editor of the professional journal Sacred Architecture.

But his latest project is a tiny chapel for a small community of cloistered Carmelite nuns who live, work and pray at the Monastery of the Infant Jesus of Prague, in the northern Michigan resort town of Traverse City. Although the chapel is also open to visitors for daily Masses and prayer — and has a loyal following among local residents — it is central to the life of the monastic community.

“The beautification of the monastery chapel is exactly the type of project that we love to do,” said Stroik. “The sisters have a great love of beauty, of the liturgy and of tradition, and want to do something worthy of Christ. I love that the project is in Traverse City because it gives me a great excuse to travel up there. The fascinating part of the project is the sisters’ desire that the sanctuary be designed to be beautiful and inspiring from the nave as well as from their cloister chapel.”

Stroik is very interested in working with a Carmelite community for the first time, particularly because the project involves the renovation of an existing sanctuary. He believes that sanctuary renovations may be one of the most important parts of the new renaissance in sacred architecture. Much of his recent work has been in renovating uninspired churches by incorporating traditional standards of dignity and beauty that had been jettisoned by modernist architects.

“What I see today is a greater appreciation for a timeless sense of architecture and art,” he said. “We have built a lot over the past four decades, and one of the best things and most economical things to do is to respond to the renewal of liturgical theology through renovation of our churches.”

The monastery, located on 60 acres of wooded land on Silver Lake Road, was built in the 1960s in the utilitarian style typical of the time. After years of prayer and thought, the nuns decided it was time to renovate the chapel sanctuary to create “an atmosphere of sacred beauty and transcendence,” reflecting their order’s tradition that every experience of beauty is an experience of God.

That sentiment dovetails perfectly with Duncan Stroik’s philosophy. As it happens, the architect was already familiar with the Traverse City area, and a priest who was visiting the monastery – Fr. Peter Stravinskas — put the sisters in touch with him.

“When I asked Fr. Peter if he knew any good church design consultants, he said, ‘I know just the man. Duncan Stroik. He’s fixed a lot of messes,’” recalled Mother Mary. “Next thing we knew, we received word from Mr. Stroik that he would be honored to do it, and so he became our architect. Only after his portfolio arrived and we recognized the St. Thomas chapel did we realize who he was!”

Not that their current chapel is ugly, the nuns are quick to assert.

“It has some very beautiful elements, but we thought it would be difficult if not impossible to give it a more traditional and transcendent look due to its structure and small size,” said Sister Perpetua Marie, the sub-prioress of the community. “When we saw pictures of some of Mr. Stroik’s renovations, suddenly new horizons opened up to us, and I became very excited.”

Stroik’s plan for the chapel begins by elevating the sanctuary altar, installing a new altar railing, marble flooring, classical architectural ornamentation that conceals the dated structural elements, new shrines to the Infant Jesus of Prague and several Carmelite saints and improved iconography with Biblical inscriptions. There will be a tabernacle prominently placed on a rear altar, reminiscent of the high altars found in European monastic churches. Visually, the sanctuary will present a unified whole, with the Eucharistic Jesus at the center, surrounded by His saints.

The architect’s initial design called for more marble, but the nuns requested wood for the columns and altar rail to give the sanctuary a Spanish aesthetic – and to aid Michigan’s economy by using local labor and materials. Even the marble dealer chosen for the project lives in Detroit.

Stroik believes that “a talented architect can find a way to create a work of art within a limited budget, mainly through an efficient though elegant design, the judicious use of fine materials, and the appropriate use of architectural detail.” The nuns have been saving toward this project for years, but are also soliciting donations from friends and supporters to bring it to completion.

“Obedience to, and love for the Church is at the core of who we are as Carmelites,” said Mother Mary. “We want to gladly receive from the Church a living tradition and then to hand it on to others by example.”

Bishop Bernard Hebda of the Diocese of Gaylord, who often visits the monastery when he’s in Traverse City – and who made it one of his first stops when he was first made bishop in 2010 — is an enthusiastic supporter of the project.

“My deepest hope is that these sisters may soon offer their praise and prayers in a setting that reflects the best of Catholic theology and the deep reverence and beauty of their personal faith,” he wrote. “At a moment when Pope Benedict has invited the Church in the English-speaking world to renew its appreciation for the Mass, and as we actively embrace a new Roman Missal which restores some of the richness of our traditions, the timing is perfect for construction of a new sanctuary within the Carmelite monastery chapel.”

The sisters at the monastery are returning the favor, donating a life-size crucifix that has hung in their sanctuary for the past 50 years to St. Mary’s Cathedral in Gaylord. The cross was made from a single redwood tree, and the image of Christ upon it was crafted in northern Italy. It is an enlarged reproduction of a treasured crucifix that the nuns keep inside their cloister and is venerated by each new sister on the day she enters the monastery and bids farewell to the world.

The project is scheduled to get under way this spring, and the nuns are hoping it will be finished by fall. The Carmelite Order, which stresses simplicity, contemplation and prayer, was founded in the 11th century on the slopes of Mt. Carmel, in what is now Israel, and spread rapidly through Europe during the Middle Ages. In the 16th century it was reformed by two of the Catholic Church’s most noted mystical writers, St. Teresa of Avila and St. John of the Cross. Today there are thousands of Carmelite sisters and brothers in 960 monasteries around the world, including three other Michigan communities in Iron Mountain, near Detroit and outside Grand Rapids.

The Traverse City monastery traces its origins to a Mexican nun’s desperate prayer when she faced a firing squad during a wave of anti-Catholic persecution in 1914. Mother Mary Elias miraculously escaped death, and went on to bring her community safely to Grand Rapids. Mother Teresa Margaret, who founded the Traverse City monastery in 1950, is the only nun still alive today who made her novitiate under Mother Elias’ direction. She celebrated her 100th birthday at the monastery in September 2011.

As members of a cloistered, contemplative order, Carmelite sisters spend their days in private and liturgical prayer, spiritual reading, and domestic tasks such as baking Communions wafers. They don’t leave the monastery except for rare occasions such as doctor appointments. Even during Masses they remain within an enclosed choir area, separated from the public area of the chapel by a metal grille – which means they will only be able to see a part of the renovation work that Stroik is performing on their behalf.

Nevertheless, Mother Mary expects it to have a positive impact on their devotional lives.
“With the renovation we will all be able to see the crucifix, a traditional tabernacle, and a new Latin inscription from Hosea: I will lead her into the desert and speak to her heart,” she said. “If we can afford it, there will also be a painting of Our Lady of Mt. Carmel with the Saints of the Carmelite Order on the back wall. We will still be in our concrete block “box” but now it will have a window into Heaven—and isn’t that what every church building should be?”

The Monastery of the Infant Jesus of Prague is located at 3501 Silver Lake Road in Traverse City.  […] Mass is celebrated at 7:30am on Sunday, Saturday and Holy days, and at 6:55am Monday through Friday. For more information about the renovation project, contact

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.


  1. Fiat says:

    Thank, Jeremy,

    I think you would be in a position to know the facts. Thanks!

  2. Jeremy Steck says:

    The Cathedral desperately needed a large crucifix and it was very nice of the sisters to donate it.

  3. Fiat says:

    :-) I’m all for common sense.

  4. OrganVirtuoso says:

    I am familiar with a church that had its side altars pulled out and burned in a bonfire. That wanton destruction is what I would call insensitivity (and stupidity). Donating a cherished part of the sanctuary to a church (the cathedral) that could really use it, especially when the net gain is so much more? That’s what I call good Catholic common sense.

  5. Fiat says:


    The crucifix being donated to the cathedral was too large in proportion to fit into the new layout which will now have the altar attached to the wall. I admit, the crucifix was the most edifying of elements present, but what else was there? That one particular crucifix to which you refer would not fit into the setting of the traditional high altar now being constructed.

    I know the Sisters well. They want to restore tradition, not eliminate it, or downplay. Don’t forget, they are also “trading-off” those old, tacky-looking, modernistic statues and replacing them with more beautiful ones, getting a communion rail, side altars, an elevated marble sanctuary floor to represent Calvary and to make ad-orientem sacrifice possible. They have already replaced their tinted plexiglass windows with beautiful, traditional-looking stained glass ones which depict OL of Mt. Carmel, Our Lord; they have restored their pipe organ, etc.

    These Sisters would put most Catholics to shame, even some Trads. They keep the Black fast on Fridays,year-round; do not eat meat; sacrifice their sleep; keep stricter fasts during Lent and Advent; wear the full, woolen habits and only sandals. They watch no Television nor read secular newspapers. I have the highest of respect for these Sisters. They are supportive of the Tridentine Mass. Perhaps we could intensify our prayers so that they could get a chaplain who would offer the TLM for them.

    Keep in mind also,the Cathedral which is getting the crucifix will benefit. I am told the place is much in need of something Catholic.

    Please support them if you are able.

    God bless.

  6. marsha says:

    4/21/2012: please tell me why the important Crucifix, which is so important to the history of this monastery is being given, sold or donated to the nearby Cathedral?
    I’m seeing more and more of this kind of insensitivity around. Was this a “trade-off” so the nuns could get the sanctuary?

  7. ihmprayforme says:

    Dear Joyce,

    I e-mailed yesterday, and voila!, the answer appeared this morning!

    Mother Prioress said to thank you for your kind interest! They have received about 1/3 of what is needed for our Lady’s side altar, and they would welcome additional donations.

    God bless you and yours!


  8. ihmprayforme says:

    Hello, Joyce,

    At this time, I do not know what has or has not been funded. I am not sure if I should write them to inquire. They are in their Lenten silence and do not carry on correspondence during this time, unless of course, it is an emergency.

    I tell you what. I will go ahead and ask Mother Prioress. If I do not hear from her within a week, I will assume that I have to wait until after Easter to get a reply. I will let you know.

    God bless!


  9. Joyce says:

    Has the Blessed Virgin shrine been funded yet?

  10. I like the sound of the plan. Can’t wait to see it finished!

  11. ihmprayforme says:

    “The architect’s initial design called for more marble, but the nuns requested wood for the columns and altar rail to give the sanctuary a Spanish aesthetic..”

    That was a good call by the nuns. The Spanish-look will better reflect their historical heritage. I think Mother Elias must be very pleased!

  12. Pingback: » More info on the Traverse City Carmelite Monastery Renovations Good Saints (Boni Sancti): Northern Michigan Catholic Dad Blog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *